What FOIR actually is
A lender doesn't offer a loan based on your full salary. It applies a ratio, commonly somewhere between 50% and 65% depending on the bank and your income level, to work out how much of your monthly income can reasonably go toward EMI payments without stretching you too thin. That capped monthly amount, minus anything you're already paying on other loans, becomes your EMI capacity, and everything else follows from there.
Where lenders genuinely differ
The FOIR percentage itself varies by lender. So does how much of your rental income, bonus income, or other non-salary income gets counted toward that capacity in the first place, and that second part is where two people with identical salaries can end up with meaningfully different offers.
A worked example
Two applicants, both salaried, both earning ₹1,20,000 a month with ₹20,000 in rental income. One applies at HDFC Bank, the other at ICICI Bank.
Same salary, same rental income, over ₹10 lakh apart in eligibility. Neither bank is wrong, they're simply weighing the same inputs differently, which is exactly why comparing a single lender's number to your friend's approval from a different bank rarely tells you much.
What this means practically
Declaring rental or other income you might otherwise leave off the application matters more at some lenders than others. And your employment category, salaried versus self-employed, government versus private, shifts both the FOIR and the rate on top of this, which compounds the gap further.
